LiveATC Discussion Forums
Air Traffic Monitoring => Listener Forum => Topic started by: chefnoel on January 27, 2009, 09:29:15 AM
-
http://www.statesman.com/news/content/gen/ap/TX_Cargo_Plane_Crash.html
-
"There is a trail of jet fuel from their impact area, which was in the grass, to where it sits now to the right of the runway north of the terminal."
I wasn't aware there was a jet-variant of the ATR-42 :wink:
Glad everyone's ok.
-
"There is a trail of jet fuel from their impact area, which was in the grass, to where it sits now to the right of the runway north of the terminal."
I wasn't aware there was a jet-variant of the ATR-42 :wink:
Glad everyone's ok.
Um........is that a joke? Or am I just really confused :?
-
You're not the only confused one.
-
Never mind, I'll go sit in the corner. Still glad everyone's ok though...
-
Never mind, I'll go sit in the corner. Still glad everyone's ok though...
It's alright i do that often too :-) i'm glad everyones okay too
-
Never mind, I'll go sit in the corner. Still glad everyone's ok though...
Haha, did somebody have a brain fart?
Don't worry, it'll happen more and more often as you get older
-
From what I've seen and read they landed short is that correct? Just tryin to get the facts for future speculation. What are the natural factors that could contribute to that? Low level windshear? Plus I dont know if they were doing an ILS or visual approach. This one will be interesting to see what actually happened and caused it. Glad they walked away though.
-
From what I've seen and read they landed short is that correct? Just tryin to get the facts for future speculation. What are the natural factors that could contribute to that? Low level windshear?
I believe the weather at the time was freezing drizzle/freezing fog. Airframe icing would be my first suspect.
-
"There is a trail of jet fuel from their impact area, which was in the grass, to where it sits now to the right of the runway north of the terminal."
For the confused:
The ATR-42 is a turboprop aircraft. It burns Jet-A ("jet fuel") to operate. Thus, the statement is correct.
Also, according to an NTSB release earlier today, the aircraft was on an ILS approach into the airport. With the freezing rain being reported, I'm also thinking aircraft icing, but it's way too early to tell, of course.
-
The ATR-42 is a turboprop aircraft.
And, wasn't it an American Airlines ATR-42 that crashed outside of Chicago in a holding pattern at 13,000 feet due to ice back in the early '90s, setting off a major advance in the understanding of the perils of airframe icing?
I am too lazy to look up the aircraft type specifically but I recall it being an ATR model.
(not that this has anything to do with the current accident under question other than bring up a discussion point)
-
Yes I believe it was. I'll see what I can find on the NTSB reports about that. Heck, there have been a couple of airframe icing accidents since then that involved airlines. I recall a CRJ in the late 90s near Detroit.
-
And, wasn't it an American Airlines ATR-42 that crashed outside of Chicago in a holding pattern at 13,000 feet due to ice back in the early '90s, setting off a major advance in the understanding of the perils of airframe icing?
I am too lazy to look up the aircraft type specifically but I recall it being an ATR model.
(not that this has anything to do with the current accident under question other than bring up a discussion point)
Pretty much...American Eagle actually (EGF). That accident led to several Airwortiness Directives for the ATR regarding the Deice boots and ailerons. Also American Eagle phased out their ATRs in that region moving the majority of them to SJU and the remainder to MIA and DFW.
Back in my deicing days in SYR, Continental Express was still flying ATRs into the airport. On the rare days it wasn't snowing the BTA ATRs would be our only customers. They'd come in with so much ice on them we'd have to deice the turn flight just to get the inbound ice off the airframe.
-
Back in my deicing days in SYR, Continental Express was still flying ATRs into the airport. On the rare days it wasn't snowing the BTA ATRs would be our only customers. They'd come in with so much ice on them we'd have to deice the turn flight just to get the inbound ice off the airframe.
Interesting information.
These days Continental's regional carriers use Dash-8s and CRJs to do their dirty work here in SYR.
-
Yes I believe it was. I'll see what I can find on the NTSB reports about that. Heck, there have been a couple of airframe icing accidents since then that involved airlines. I recall a CRJ in the late 90s near Detroit.
Comair (3272?) EMB-120 Brasilia, CVG-DTW
-
Here is what I found on the NTSB website with regard to In-flight icing encounters for airlines:
American Eagle Flight 4184, 10/31/1994, ATR-72, Indiana
Comair Flight 3272, 1/9/1997, Embraer-120 near Monroe, MI
-
The Eagle Flight incident is an interesting read from the cockpit voice recorder transcripts. The pilots commented a couple times on the deck angle and considered dialing in some flaps. In a nutshell the autopilot held the aircraft until it couldnt hold it anymore and disconnected. Pretty much handed the crew an already out of control airplane.